[Photo: Eddie Carmel, the Jewish Giant, in 1961]

home > on-air > feature documentaries >

The Jewish Giant
Recorded in New York City.
Premiered October 6, 1999, on All Things Considered.


Photographer Jenny Carchman was eight years old in 1979 when her mother first showed her Diane Arbus' collection of photos (diane arbus, 1971, Aperture). There were pages of "freaks" -- midgets, transvestites, dwarves, hermaphrodites, naked people and the like. She remembers her mother pausing in the middle of the book on a photo of a very large man, towering above an older couple. The caption read, "Jewish Giant at Home with His Parents in the Bronx, NY, 1970." Her mother told her that the giant in the photo was named Eddie Carmel. He was her cousin. Eddie had died two years after the photo was taken, a year after Jenny was born. This was the first she had heard of him.

As a child, Jenny couldn't get Eddie out of her mind: the freakish son in the dark Bronx living room, his parents looking up at him with wonder and sorrow. She had nightmares for weeks. She felt that if she touched that photo, she too would turn into a giant. Her fears were magnified by the silence surrounding her cousin. For years, whenever she'd try to talk about Eddie, her family refused to discuss him.

The Jewish Giant began with Jenny's search to uncover a story that has remained a secret for 25 years. Eddie was normal sized until he became a teenager, when he began to grow uncontrollably (he suffered from acromegaly, a then-incurable condition resulting from a tumor that had developed on his pituitary gland). According to The Guiness Book of World Records, Eddie grew to be 8'9". As an adult, the only work he could find involved exploiting his freakishness. He starred in B-grade monster movies (The Brain that Wouldn't Die), made two 45 records ("The Happy Giant" and "The Good Monster") and was billed in the Ringling Brothers Circus at Madison Square Garden as "The Tallest Man on Earth." Eddie died in 1972 at the age of 36 in Montefiore Hospital in the Bronx. His coffin was custom made.

The Jewish Giant is a story of suffering, of not fitting in, of the body betraying itself, and of the bizarre life-twists that can subsume a family. It's a story about what it's like to be a regular person looking at the world from inside a not-so-regular body.

Producer: Stacy Abramson / Narrator: Jenny Carchman / Executive Producer: David Isay / Production Assistant: Meagan Howell / Music: Henry Sapoznik and Pete Sokolow / Supervising Engineer: Caryl Wheeler / Funding provided by the National Endowment for the Arts, the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, and the Greenwall Foundation. Special thanks to Andy Lanset and Ellen Weiss.

 

LISTEN
Please consider supporting the work of Sound Portraits and StoryCorps by making a donation.

LISTEN
This piece is available in the following audio formats [28:14 min]:
MP3

READ
intro
transcript

MORE

The Jewish Giant on CD

"Jewish Giant at Home with His Parents in the Bronx, NY, 1970," the Diane Arbus photo that inspired this documentary



YOU ARE HERE: home > on-air > feature documentaries > THE JEWISH GIANT

email this page | top of page



 

home  |  ON-AIR |  in-print |  about |  education |  support |  store

Sound Portraits Productions, 80 Hanson Place, 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Telephone (646) 723-7020 | Fax (646) 723-7026

Copyright © 2014 Sound Portraits Productions. All rights reserved.